At the counter
Buying your first few
Buy singles before boxes. A box is a commitment to one blend in one size. Three or four singles across the strength range will teach you far more about your own palate.
Start milder than your pride suggests. Nicotine strength sneaks up on people, especially on an empty stomach. A mild or mild-medium cigar after a meal is the gentlest introduction; have a glass of water and something sweet within reach.
Pick a medium size. A robusto (about 5 × 50) or a corona-sized cigar gives you the blend's character in under an hour. A seven-inch Churchill is a long evening.
Ask two questions. "How strong is it?" and "what does it taste like?" Good tobacconists answer both, and they'll often steer you right if you name a drink you like.
Give them a rest. Cigars bought from a well-kept shop are ready to smoke, but a couple of weeks in your own humidor at 65–70% lets them settle after the trip home. Shipped cigars especially benefit.
Keep notes. Name, size, wrapper, what you drank, what you tasted. After half a dozen entries you'll start to see your own preferences — that's the whole point of the shelf.