Thanksgiving is a week from today. Across much of the country the furnace is running, the porch is cold, and the cigar that behaved all summer is suddenly cracking, tunneling or going out. Nothing is wrong with the cigars. The season changed, and the way we keep and smoke them has to change with it. This week, a practical guide to cold-weather cigar season.
Why your house turns into a desert
Boveda, the humidity-control company, sums up winter's problem in two lines: cold outdoor air holds less moisture, and indoors the heating system is pushing out dry air. Here's the arithmetic behind it. Take outdoor air at 32°F and a damp 80 percent relative humidity. Warm that same air to 68°F inside your house without adding any water, and its relative humidity falls to roughly 21 percent. The water didn't go anywhere. Air at 68°F can simply hold nearly four times as much, so the same amount of water is now a much smaller share.
A humidor wants something like 65 to 72 percent, Boveda's recommended range. A wooden humidor isn't airtight, and Cigar Aficionado notes that it isn't meant to be. So all winter, a box sitting in 20-something-percent air is losing a slow tug-of-war. Glass-top and inexpensive humidors have it worst. Boveda says they might be off by 2 to 5 points or more.
Keeping the box steady
Move it away from the heat. Cigar Aficionado warns against temperature extremes, including direct sun and a spot on top of a radiator. In winter that also means off the mantel and away from vents and baseboard heaters. An inside wall in a cooler room is a good home.
Check the gauge, then check the cigars. Boveda recommends recalibrating a hygrometer every six months, and late fall is a sensible time to do it. But Cigar Aficionado's rule beats any gauge: "If the cigars are exuding a little oil, the conditions are perfect. If they seem too dry, you add more water."
Feed it more, and feed it right. Expect to refill a sponge, bead or gel humidifier more often than you did in July, and use distilled water. Minerals in tap water build up on the device and clog it. If you use two-way humidity packs in a wooden humidor, Boveda suggests stepping up a level for the dry months, for example from 69 to 72 percent, then stepping back down in spring. It also says to double the pack count in a drafty box, to never mix RH levels in one humidor, and to keep its 75 percent packs out of airtight containers like bags and tupperdors.
Go slow. When the needle dips, resist leaving a wet sponge in the box or the lid open. Add a little moisture and give it a few days. A gradual drift is easier on cigars than a sudden swing.
New arrivals wait in the lobby
Holiday cigars tend to arrive in the mail, and a box that spent three days on a cold truck shouldn't go straight in with the rest. Cigars trade moisture with each other, Boveda points out, so a dry newcomer will pull from your settled stock. Its advice is to rest new cigars first in something sealed, such as a humidor bag or a lidded plastic container with a humidity pack, give them at least a week, and then move them into the wooden box.
What the cold really does to a cigar
Less than you'd think, and more than you'd like. A Cigar Aficionado editor put the case against freezing-weather smoking plainly: cigars are "handmade items born in the tropics," and in extreme cold "wrappers crack, moisture freezes, combustion slows." The cigar-review site Would Smoke Again adds a useful distinction. Moderate cold doesn't hurt the tobacco itself. What it hurts is the burn, because a coal sheds heat faster in cold air, runs cooler and goes out more easily. The cracking mostly comes from dryness, not the cold. The wrapper loses moisture from the outside in and shrinks against a filler that hasn't shrunk yet, and the thin outer leaf gives way.
Wind is worse than cold
Cigar Aficionado's editors do their blind tastings indoors for a reason: wind makes lighting difficult, pushes the cigar to burn unevenly or hot, changes the flavor, and carries the aroma off before you smell it. A breeze cools the coal on one side and feeds it on the other, which is how most winter canoes start. The fix is where you stand, not how you puff. Put a wall, a corner or the side of the house between you and the wind, and touch up a lagging edge early, before it becomes a canoe.
The lighter that quits
If your torch sputters on a cold night, that's physics, not a defect. A butane lighter works because the liquid fuel boils into gas when you open the valve, and ordinary butane boils at about 31°F. Near freezing it barely turns to vapor, so the flame goes short and weak and then quits. Isobutane, which some refills blend in, keeps vaporizing down to about 11°F. Either way, keep the lighter in an inside pocket against your body, fill it before you go out, and plan on a longer toast and at least one relight.
Choosing a cold-weather cigar
The experts disagree, sort of, and both sides have a point. Cigar Aficionado's advice for smoking in the elements is to skip the delicate, elegant cigars and anything small or thin that will "lose their glow," and to choose full-flavored cigars "with enough girth to stay lit." Would Smoke Again argues for going shorter, because a robusto you finish in about forty minutes beats a churchill you abandon halfway with numb hands, and the shorter cigar spends less time drying out in the open air. Put the two together and you get the classic winter cigar: short and thick. A robusto or a short toro in a bold blend, something like the Partagás Serie D No. 4 that Cigar Aficionado named for outdoor smoking, gives the coal enough mass to stay lit and gets you back inside before your toes go numb. Save your rare, aged and mild cigars for a comfortable chair indoors.
The out-and-back routine
Before you go out: cut the cigar indoors, where the cap is still warm and flexible. A cold, stiff wrapper can tear under a cutter. If you'll be walking a while before you light, carry the cigar in a tube or a travel case in an inside pocket, and leave the cellophane on until you're ready.
Out there: wear thin gloves, not mittens. With bulky gloves you can't feel how hard you're squeezing, and a crushed cigar draws badly for the rest of its life. Smoke slowly so the cigar doesn't run hot, and keep the lighter warm between touch-ups.
Coming back in: this is the step most people skip. A cold cigar carried into a warm room gathers condensation like a cold glass, and a damp wrapper shut in a box is how mold gets started. Let any unsmoked cigars warm up on the counter for about an hour, still in their case or cellophane, before they go back in the humidor. And don't use the car as a humidor. It has no humidity control and swings widely in temperature between afternoon and dawn.
The Thanksgiving porch
Thursday's cigar usually gets lit after the pie, outside, in the dark, with whoever's willing to grab a coat. Choose the size by how long you can stand the cold, not how long you'd like to stay out. Bring a tube for anyone you're sharing with, find a spot out of the wind and away from the door so the smoke doesn't drift back into the house. If it's truly bitter, take Cigar Aficionado's advice and move it indoors to a cigar lounge or a friend's cigar-friendly room. As that same editor put it: "Bring a bottle of Scotch. Peaty. Remember, it's cold out there."
